Which is totally better than old crap that I hate night!!! Or country isn’t there another show for that night!!! The Idol gods must have liked that offering I made to them because this week the Idols get to pick their songs. Fuh-INALLY. Also, it’s coming on the right night.
Anoop – First up – An(ew)p – oh he picked Usher, what a moron. His voice sounds ok but he’s trying to be all sexy? or something? I don’t know, it’s making me feel uncomfortable.
Like, ok, this one time, in college, there was this frat rat and he was cute and all. Then at a party he came up to me and pulled me to the dance floor and grinded my ass. Gross! I didn’t ask for an ass grinding jerk! Anoop’s little performance is like that, except he’s grinding on my ears and my eyes. Make it stop!
Noob totally rips him a new one! Wow! Love her!
And Paula! So tan! By the end of this season she’s going to be a new Star Trek race. hee, she uses the word balladeer then follows it up with complete nonsense.
Simon calls him a “wanna be” (totally true, totally true) and something about a bad frat performance – cut to his frat brothers acting like, well frat boys – which is too say, pretty damn drunk.
Then Anoop does the contestant kiss of death. He gets pissy. Don’t. get. pissy. He’s all ‘I’m an R & B artist and blah blah blah Usher cakes blah blah America blah.” Anoop. Shut. tit. Shutitirightonup. Because, here’s the thing (to quote Noob) – there are many R & B artists that you could emulate. Ugly Babyface comes to mind. You don’t need to bump and wear shoulder chains like Usher because you can’t pull that off. That’s what the judges were saying and you should have listened. Lucky for you, Megan is up next.
Megan – So here it is, the song that got Megan booted. And boy does it suck! I’m clapping and bouncing on the couch, just enjoying the pure suck. I like Megan cause she’s cute and she’s a mom but man, she just is not a performer. Plus, she has no clue how bad she is. Most contestants will get that worry line on their forehead when they are this bad but not Megan! Her voice sounds like she’s recording a Chipmunks soundtrack.
The amount of necklaces she’s wearing is insane! Are you fleeing the Titanic or something?
Noob calls her “irritating”. Daaaammmmn Noob where have you been all this time?
Paula suggest she digs deep – hee hee. I don’t know why I laugh but it sounds dirty to me.
Then Megan does a series of annoying hand signals and buh bye. Though I did tear up a little when she got to tell her little girl she was coming home and she seemed really happy about that. Annnnd -
IDOL RANT INTERLUDE
You know what? Idol really should take better care of the parents/children on this show. I know Lil has managed to have her family there for some of it but Michael (kicked off), Alexis (kicked off) and Megan (kicked off) have all talked about the strain of being away from their babies. Micheal seemed especially sad at having to try to explain to his 3 year old why he couldn’t come home.
And to say nothing of the children. That 3 year old was seriously hurting. Now you can make the argument that should these people make a record, land big then touring will take them away. But – they aren’t big yet, they may never be big and it isn’t just about them but the kids. Fantasia was a mom and a superstar so Idol should respect it because at the very least they may get a ton of money out of these parents.
Ok, that’s all – stepping down now.
IDOL RANT OVER
oooh tomorrow night they debut the David Cook video! I’m so there.
Gokey – he picks What Hurts the Most by Rascal Flats. This song is so stupid.
Yay! Fan signage – Go Go Gokey. Meh, pretty cute. I think Gokey is Hokey is probably more accurate.
The songs is bad I think. He’s drowned out by the background music and he, like Anoop is wearing chains. Someone explain chains as accessories to me please.
The judges all love it. I hate when that happens. Then Gokey rambles on about the song and connecting and you know what? Don’t lecture me Gokey. You’re on American Idol that means you shut up, you wear chains and bad suits and you smile and then I vote for you.
Allison – Don’t Speak – oooooohhhh terrible song choice. Damn, and I love Allison so much. But she should have gone with Pink or Toni Braxton. Am I right?
She sings good of course but it’s just simply the wrong song. Though I applaud her cosplay hair. And, unlike the judges, I like the outfit. It’s got ruffles and is no worse than the chain wear and corset we’ve seen tonight.
This bad choice lands her in the bottom three but the judges make it pretty clear that if this happens again they will save her. Good. But senorita? DON’T let this happen again.
Scott – YAY! He picks Just the Way you Are and is going to “strip things down”. mmmmm, strip. He rocks it tonight. It’s a lovely song and he’s a lovely singer. I’m not sure if his voice is strong enough to take him to the finals but I do enjoy it.
His hair is a little stiff and, uh, that chest hair puff can go but overall – I don’t know, he’s so appealing to me. Even with his fang teeth. I just -
I love you Scott. Have I said that? On Idol Tonight they asked the contestants what their first concert was and Scott was all, “Amy Grant when I was 6.” But not in an isn’t-that-embarrassing way more like an isn’t-that-fun-and-awesome way. He’s unabashedly Amy Grant and that’s just so… I don’t know. I love you Scott! If I weren’t busy having my husband’s babies I would totally have yours! I would!
Ok, ahem – judging.
Noob – “I love your new looks” Uh, is she blind? (hee). I miss his old hair.
Paula reminds us all of his “challenge” while pointing out that he’s “challenged”. Which, really, hasn’t seemed to be a big deal at all.
Matt – You Found Me by the Fray. The who now? Poor Matt, so desperate, so vulnerable talking about being in the bottom three. Must not be won over – must resist sympathy pull.
Oh, a keyboard in the audience and a suck song? That should do it. He’s mumbly, speak up Matt. Or don’t cause this song is clearly awful.
The judges rip him. But he’s not even in the bottom three. Whatever.
Lil – singing I Surrender by Celine Dion. Wow. Interesting choice.
She comes out in some whore makeup – so far, so Celine. What’s with the dress though? Is the wardrobe budget in trouble or something?
Do I even need to tell you that her voice sounds powerful and great? Cause it does. This is a safe song for her. Not that that’s a bad thing, especially at this point.
The judges disagree, telling her to “young it up”. But there’s such a market for a voice like Lil’s and no, it’s not Generation PepsiNext but who needs those illegal downloaders anyway?
Kris – Ain’t No Sunshine
He sounds good. Generic – ugh, Idol director stop it with those red lights already.
I don’t have much to say about Kris. He wiggles in his stool which is weird. I just don’t see anything original or special in him. Sorry.
Adam – I missed most of this on account of bath giving but in the playback it looked pretty cool. I maybe going over to the dark side here.
But if he reapplies one centimeter of black eyeliner, that’s it.
but Luke Menard? Meh. I don’t see much of his tune. I come in right as Ryan is comparing him to
Oh, no, it’s Robbie Carrico or however you spell it. I missed him last week and I was hoping to miss him this week. Damn. The intro videos this week feature the question: “What would people be surprised to find out about you?” Um, is anyone surprised to find out Robbie is a drag queen?
Since my lova Colton was booted, now I must cherish sweet Danny Noriega. Did you know – he was in a punk rock band?? I’m shocked! No, not really.
David Hernandez was a gymnast – oh yeah, shocking. He does realize he’s on American Idol and not American Gladiators, right? Cause gymnists and flutists are like the Smiths of Idoland.
Jason Yeager plays multiple instruments – badly. Awww he’s kind of a cutie. That hair has got to go though.
Here’s another one I am determined to hate Chikezie – but then he tells a sweet story about how his name is actually an African name with a certain dialect. No one can pronounce it and a teacher just started calling him “Chikezie” so he went with it. That. is. adorable. Chikezie is so cuddly.
David Cook is a word nerd. Is he, like, addicted to that scarf? Take it from my friend Ben Agee – signature items like this fucking scarf will get your ass beat in jail.
David Archuleta – screeeeeeeeaaaaammm, faaaaaiiinnntt
Next up was Joanna “I went Home” Borgella.
Here’s the Oklahoma girl – Alaina “Carrie Underwood is my Clone” Whitaker.
The token rocker Amanda “Mumbles” Overmyer -
Here comes Alexandrea “It’s DRAY_AH get it right” Lushington
Next in line is Kady “Britney Spears” Malloy
Asiah “Did I mention my Dad is dead. Cause he is. I have a dead dad.” Eperson
Following that is Ramiele “Little People, Big World” Malubay
Syesha “WhyMesha” Mercado
Carly “Don’t Believe the Hype” Smithson
Ok, back to Danny Morita/Noriega. We have to suffer through his stupid interview where he blathers on about being himself blah blah. Finally, we Danny in all his glory. Tight black pants, skinny tie, strutting like he owns the gayborhood. I love it.
Next up is Luck Manard. He tells us that he’s a carpet cleaner….in porn. I mean, seriously, carpet cleaners are not this good looking! He’s wearing a parka, indoors. Enough said there.
Moving on we get Colton Berry, which sounds like some kind of cereal for weightlifters. He’s like a vanilla Danny Noriega, Noriega Lite. And sometimes, you need a lighter lunch you know what I mean?
Following Colton is the unfortunate Garret Haley. He’s been compared to
Out comes Jason Castro, what’s with these names??? He’s a hippy. Who plays guitar, or at least strums a few cords. He sings Daydreaming Boy. I hate this song, it’s so stupid. But I have to admit, this guy is a good performer. Obviously the ladies love him, the top 12 girls are like cuming in their seats I swear. They keep wiggling around…
But Michael Johns cares nothing for that. He’s a 29 year old Australian. I think it’s cute how he thinks we might not vote for him because he’s an Aussie and not because he’s got that scarf on. He’s pretty cute but a little on the old side…
EWWWW AI country week
It was 7:15 before I realized I was missing Idol. I mean, all the family time dinnery stuff is nice but WTF self??? It’s IDOL!!! So I ran into the living room and discovered I had only missed one person. One person. In 15 minutes. They really like to drag this out don’t they.
Oh and look, it’s country week. BOOOOO. Randy Travis is the guest mentor. Yuk. Wow, he’s so skinny and square headed. Has he always looked like this?
Second up, first for me is
Allison – Yay! I’m so glad I didn’t miss her. She’s singing Blame it on Your Heart. Her voice sounds a little shakey but still pretty awesome. What I take issue with is – the “look”. I get that it’s country but damn, there is never EVER a reason for feathered hair like that. Let’s also talk for a minute about the dress over the jeans combo. Ladies. Dresses and jeans do not belong together. Maybe hanging in the closet but never on your body. The dress/jean combo is something a drunk college student wears when they go to the lake.
oooh, Paula is, like, super tan – even tanner than last week.
Kris – singing Garth Brooks. Blech. Garth is the worst. I’m sorry but he is. I worked as a mascot moose for a country station one year and my ears would literally bleed all day long thanks to Mr. Brooks.
Turns out the only thing worse than Garth is Kris. Randy is totally flirting with him, calling Kris a Tender Dog. At least Kris has the good sense to hate that. He says that he’s glad Kris didn’t “imitate” Garth.
Danny: Sometimes they don’t and they should.
Word, Danny. Kris is using the prop chair (boo), is clean shaven (yay), boring (boo) and sounds real pop (boo/yay but in this case boo).
Paula’s tanning must have fried her brain cause she is really on a delayed schedule tonight. Love it.
Lil – comes out in a pink hankerchief. Great for giant sneezes, not so much for singing in. She’s singing Independance Day and Randy comments that she’s got “big pipes on the top”. Which is country for “boooooooobbs”, I guess. Ugh, god country. This dumb song encapsulates everything I hate about the genre – the twang, the “story”, the neverending sobbing – oh that last one was just me.
Lil has a strong voice though and hits an awesome last note. Go Lil! The judges aren’t really into it though. Noob hands out some decent advice but Randy and Paula just babble. Then comes Simon who calls her “little”. Then continues to do it. I’m sorry, I get that Simon is the jerk or whatever but not addressing someone by their proper name is just straight rude.
Adam – ah I see, he and Paula are in a tanning competition. He looks horrible per usual. Fingerless gloves, really Adam? And that jacket. They show some clip of Randy hating on Adam and being befuddled by the black fingernails. Randy reveals himself to be either: 1. incredibly sheltered or 2. kind of an ass – I’m guessing a little of both – when he muses that he’s never seen a *gasp* man wearing nail polish.
Adam launches into a bizarre rendition of Ring of Fire. It’s really just… I don’t know, creepy and weird and he sings it with zero sense of irony. But he does do some insane stuff with his voice.
Yay! The Paula Seal Clap.
Randy thinks it’s like 9 Inch Nails doing Ring of Fire and I totally totally disagree. Simon says it was “indulgent rubbish” and he’s right.
mmmm, Bret Harrison. The Reaper is on during Idol so I get quick Bret fixes on the commercials.
Scott – YAYAYAYAYAYAY!! I was worried I missed him. He sings Wild Angles which…sorry to say…is not a good song for him. It’s pretty of course but a little flat. It gets better at the end.
My god, is a stupid jacket a prerequisite for stepping on the Idol stage? The crowd loves him and I do to. I love you Scott.
Paula rambles about him needing to connect with the audience and get away from the piano. Scott is all, “We can move it closer.” Hahaha. So cute. I love you. I love you Scott.
Alexis – ohhhh, trying Dolly Parton. Eesh. Alexis, let’s have a chat. Girl, you know I like you with your cute daughter and your pink hair. That hair is a little too poofy tonight but still – you’re cute. So, Dolly huh? Well, here’s the thing – you? are NOT Dolly Parton. Unless you can pack a combination of anger, self pity and a quiet strength into ONE word then god please do not attempt this song.
Bitch doesn’t listen and screws up Jolene big time.
My lord, what is with contestants pleading their case this year? This isn’t Survivor. If you want to stay around, then SING well enough to do it.
Danny – singing Jesus Take the Wheel. Oh, Jesus.
Another jacket? Jesus. He’s cutely nervous but, jesus, do I hate this song. Het tit. The awkward rhymes, the story, the use of a grown woman saying “mama and daddy” – I mean, jeeeeeeebus.
hahaha, Fox likes it though. He claps and goes, “yay!”.
Megan – Randy Travis seems a little doubtful but then gushes about her rendition of Walking After Midnight. So I’m all stoked but…uh, it’s just kind of dumb. She’s weird and does nothing to improve on the original. The crowd loves it cause they too are dumb.
That dress is gorgeous though and her arm tattoo looks cool with it.
Ah, ok, she’s got the flu so we should all be impressed. I bet the CDC is thrilled.
Matt – sings So Small. I can’t understand him at all. They compare him to Michael Buble – again, that’s not a good thing.
Paula is drifting….
So the two I missed (I missed another person while getting Fox ready for bed), I catch in the numbers recap.
Michael – real country
Anoop – seems like he sounded really good
Aaaaannnndd, breath. Country week is OVER!!
Who should go: Adam, Megan or Matt
Who will probably go: Anoop or possibly Lil
Who I want in the finals: Allison and Scott
→ Leave a comment
Posted in AI
Tagged american idol, commentary, country night, season 8, top 11